Hello, this is the Miami Running Crew!
Recently, one of our crew members suffered a minor ankle sprain during a
weekend trail running training session. Fortunately, it wasn't a serious
injury, but it prompted us to have an in-depth discussion about the trail
running shoes our team members wear. Among our six team members, four wear
Arc'teryx trail running shoes, one wears Hoka Speedgoat 6 GTX, and I wear
Salomon trail running shoes. Based on our individual experiences, we'd like to
share an honest review of these three popular trail running shoes and help you
consider which shoe might be best suited for your trail running.
Trail running is an appealing sport
that allows you to enjoy nature while navigating unpredictable terrain.
However, the role of shoes in protecting your feet and ankles and providing
stable traction is crucial. Which trail running shoe will deliver the best
performance and safety? Let's take a closer look at the pros and cons of each
shoe, along with our crew's vivid experiences.
1. Hoka Speedgoat 6 GTX: The
Powerhouse of Ankle Protection and Traction
One of our crew members wears the Hoka
Speedgoat 6 GTX, a model well-known in the trail running shoe market for its
thick cushioning and excellent stability. As the 'GTX' in its name suggests, it
uses Gore-Tex material for superior waterproofing, making it ideal for trail
running in winter or wet conditions.
Pros:
•Excellent Traction: The Vibram
Megagrip outsole and 3.9mm lug depth provide stable traction on various
terrains. It offers reliable performance even on wet surfaces or slippery
rocks.
•Strong Ankle Protection: According to
user experience, it provides a strong, secure fit around the foot and ankle,
offering excellent stability. This greatly helps reduce the risk of injury on
trails.
•Ample Cushioning: The 32.9mm heel
stack and 27.9mm forefoot stack provide sufficient cushioning to reduce foot
fatigue during long runs. It's particularly suitable for midfoot and forefoot
strikers.
•Durability: The toebox, heel padding,
and outsole are all highly durable, allowing for long-term use in rugged trail
environments.
•Waterproof Functionality: Thanks to
the Gore-Tex membrane, your feet can stay comfortable even in wet and muddy
conditions.
Cons:
•Lack of Breathability: Due to the
nature of Gore-Tex, breathability is almost non-existent, which can lead to
sweaty feet in hot weather. This might cause discomfort during long runs.
•Narrow Toebox: The toebox is designed
to be narrow, which might be uncomfortable for runners with wide feet or those
who prefer more toe splay. It might feel a size too small, so consider sizing
up.
•Stiff Feel: The midsole is relatively
firm (25.8 HA), so some runners might not find the plush cushioning they
expect. It might not be ideal for heel strikers.
Overall: The Hoka Speedgoat 6 GTX is
highly recommended for runners who prioritize ankle protection and traction,
and primarily enjoy running in wet and rugged trail environments. However,
breathability and toebox width are factors to consider based on personal preference.
2. Arc'teryx Norvan LD3: Lightweight
and Robust Protection
Four of our crew members chose the
Arc'teryx Norvan LD3 trail running shoe. This shoe boasts excellent protection
and robustness despite its light weight, and it's designed for long-distance
trail running.
Pros:
•Lightweight and Robust: It's
lightweight yet durably constructed, protecting your feet from various impacts
on the trail without adding burden.
•Excellent Breathability: It offers
superior breathability, helping to keep your feet comfortable during long runs.
•Stable Fit: Provides a secure and
stable fit, with the Ariaprene® foam tongue offering a sock-like comfort.
•Superior Traction: The 4mm Vibram
Megagrip lugs deliver excellent traction on diverse terrains.
•Toebox Protection: The toebox is
comfortable and highly protective, effective in preventing toe injuries.
Cons:
•Sizing Issues: According to user
experience, it runs about one size larger than usual. This can lead to the foot
feeling loose inside the shoe even with two pairs of thick socks, potentially
causing ankle sprains. This is especially noticeable on unstable terrains like
gravel paths.
•Firm Midsole: The midsole feels
relatively firm, so some runners might not find the plush cushioning they
expect. Foot fatigue might set in faster during long runs.
•High Heel Stack: The 29mm high heel
stack can compromise stability and increase the risk of ankle sprains. Caution
is needed, especially on technical trails.
Overall: The Arc'teryx Norvan LD3 is
an attractive trail running shoe with lightweight construction, excellent
breathability, and robust protection. However, careful consideration of sizing
is crucial, and the high heel stack and firm midsole are factors to weigh based
on individual running style and preference. Runners with a history of ankle
injuries should be particularly cautious.
3. Salomon Trail Running Shoes:
Balance of Stability and Traction
The Salomon trail running shoes I
personally wear generally fit my feet well and provide a sense of safety on the
trails. Salomon is particularly renowned for its excellent traction and
durability, offering models suitable for various trail environments.
Pros:
•Excellent Stability: It provides
stable support for the foot, increasing confidence in movements on the trail.
It holds the foot well, preventing wobbling even on uneven terrain.
•Strong Traction: Salomon's trail
running shoes typically feature deep and distinct lugs, providing superior
traction in various conditions like mud, rocks, and wet surfaces. (e.g.,
Salomon Genesis's 4.0mm multi-shaped lugs)
•Durability: Built to withstand harsh
trail environments, ensuring long-term use.
•Variety of Models: You can choose
from models with various cushioning, support, and waterproofing features to
suit your specific needs.
Cons:
•Insufficient Cushioning: According to
user experience, the cushioning might feel somewhat lacking. Especially during
long runs, foot fatigue might set in faster compared to shoes with more ample
cushioning.
•Weight: Some models might feel
heavier compared to lightweight trail running shoes from other brands. (e.g.,
Salomon Genesis is 9.95 oz / 282g)
•Breathability: Breathability can vary
by model, and some waterproof models might have limited breathability.
Overall: Salomon trail running shoes
are an excellent choice for runners seeking safe trail running with stable fit
and strong traction. However, if you prefer plush cushioning or extreme
lightweight shoes, you might need to consider other models. Nevertheless, stability
and traction on the trail remain Salomon's greatest strengths.
Conclusion and Recommendation: Finding
Your Perfect Trail Running Shoe
Through the Miami Running Crew's
experience, we've explored the pros and cons of three popular trail running
shoes: Hoka Speedgoat 6 GTX, Arc'teryx Norvan LD3, and Salomon trail running
shoes. Each shoe has its unique strengths and weaknesses, and rather than
declaring one as the absolute best, the optimal choice depends on your
individual running style, preferred terrain, and foot characteristics.
In summary:
•Hoka Speedgoat 6 GTX: Ideal for
runners who prioritize ankle protection and excellent traction, and desire
stable running in wet and rugged trail environments. However, breathability and
a narrow toebox are factors to consider.
•Arc'teryx Norvan LD3: A good choice
for runners who prefer lightweight, excellent breathability, and robust
protection. However, extreme caution is needed in sizing, and the high heel
stack and firm midsole can be drawbacks for runners with a history of ankle
injuries or those who prefer plush cushioning.
•Salomon Trail Running Shoes: Ideal
for runners who seek safe trail running with a stable fit and strong traction.
While cushioning might feel somewhat lacking, it provides reliable performance
on various terrains.
Miami Running Crew's Advice:
1.Try them on and feel them: The best
way is to visit a store, try them on, and even walk or run a short distance.
It's crucial to feel the fit, ankle support, and toebox comfort directly.
2.Consider your running style and
terrain: Think about what kind of terrain (rocks, dirt paths, mud, etc.) you
primarily run on, and what your running style (heel strike, midfoot strike,
etc.) is, then match it with the shoe's characteristics.
3.Sock compatibility is also
important: As seen in the Arc'teryx case, the combination of shoe size and sock
thickness is important. We recommend trying on shoes with the socks you
normally wear.
4.Use reviews as a reference only:
Other people's reviews are good references, but since everyone's foot shape and
running habits are different, it's wise to use them as a guide rather than
blindly following them.
Trail running is a sport where
equipment selection is crucial. We hope this review helps you choose your next
trail running shoe. Happy and safe trail running!